Ted Lasso, Rom-Coms, and Emotional Vulnerability

Why is it important that a show about men who play soccer did a rom-com homage?

Dickinson Behind-the-Scenes: An Interview With the Artisans

Meet the artists who brought the Apple TV+ series to life!

If You Like This, Watch That

Looking for a new TV series to watch? We recommend them based on your preference for musicals, ensemble shows, mysteries, and more!

Showing posts with label relationships. Show all posts
Showing posts with label relationships. Show all posts

Saturday, February 20, 2016

Dear TV Writers: Your Fear of The 'Moonlighting Curse' is Killing Your Show


When I was a senior in high school, preparing to leave for college, my friend Lauren stumbled into a dilemma. She had been accepted to two different universities, each with scholarships. And she didn't know where to go. Her reasoning was that she didn't want to choose the wrong school. While we had this conversation outside of our church, the youth pastor walked by. Lauren explained her problem and our youth pastor said something that's resonated with me ever since: "Sometimes there isn't a right choice and a wrong choice. Sometimes, you just have to choose."

As a writer, I think about this a lot when it comes to characters and plot in stories. Sometimes there isn't necessarily a wrong or a correct way to end or progress a story. Sometimes you just have to make a decision and commit wholeheartedly. It's the "wholeheartedly" part that television writers often fail to do, and lukewarm plots and character arcs are easily felt by the audience and detested just as much. If a writer doesn't commit to a story or to a character pairing, neither will we. 

But what I've noticed in my time watching and writing about television for years critically is that fear permeates a lot of writers' rooms, and never leaves — especially when it comes to writing romances between lead characters. It's this fear that ends up sinking shows in the end, in ways that Nielsen ratings never could. Over the years, television writers have fallen into this trap, lured there by a lie: if will-they-won't-they couples have their tension resolved and don't have to endure trope after trope of relationship drama, audiences will become bored and the show will sink faster than you can say "Titanic." Writers and producers have isolated this problem and shoved it into a grenade, placed it in the corner of a room, and moved as far away as possible from it.

The problem here is that they've failed to isolate the real danger. While writers and producers have shoved "resolved romance" into that grenade, fearing the day it blows up in their faces, they've not noticed the poisonous fruit they've picked up in its place. It's alluring to writers — to want to smash characters together and then create unnecessary drama, or to ignore romance altogether even though the story is moving in that direction.

And while I ponder what causes writers to become so afraid of writing real, functional romance in television, I find myself moving back toward what is called the "Moonlighting Curse." I'm actually going to break this piece up into three different parts. First, I'll introduce exactly what this "curse" is and why it doesn't exist. Then, I'll talk about how the perception of the curse and its effects have impacted television shows in two different "camps" — either by causing writers to create unnecessary, trope-y drama for established characters, or by causing the writers to forgo writing romance altogether. 

Ready? Set? Let's dive in!

drama boy meets world dramatic dun dun dun

DUN, DUN DUNNNNNNN — THE MOONLIGHTING CURSE EXPLAINED


Moonlighting was a show that ran on television from 1985-1989. It starred Bruce Willis (then still an up-and-coming young actor) and Cybill Shepherd. It was actually a pretty big ratings success. In the course of two seasons, it earned 16 Emmy nominations. Needless to say, audiences and critics alike loved it. (Aside: I've never actually seen the show myself, so this is just based on what I've read.) So, you might be wondering if Moonlighting was such a hit, why would there be a curse named after it? I'm glad you asked!

In the show's third season, the will-they-won't-they tension between Willis and Shepherd's characters David and Maddie comes to a head and they sleep together. After that, the series' ratings began to decline, leading to its eventual cancellation. However — this is super important — a lot of factors played into Moonlighting's eventual end. Cybill Shepherd was pregnant in real life and had to be out of the show for periods of time. This proved to be problematic, as the two main characters were not together for a lot of the fourth season. As you might expect, the editing and splicing of scenes shot pre-pregnancy led to problems, too. Add in new executive producers and a head writer four seasons into an established show, and it's no wonder the series began to sink.

As you might be able to deduce, it was hardly the show's decision to put its two leads together that led to Moonlighting's demise. It's pretty obvious that a variety of factors, most of them outside of the hands of the people writing and producing the show, were responsible for its decline. And yet, in spire of the fact that this is the logical conclusion, so many writers on television today cling to fear of this "curse" and stifle their own shows in the process (then cite the blame on things that were not to blame at all, but we'll get to that later).

It's like... it's like in theatre. If you aren't familiar, there's this legend in the theatre that if you say "Macbeth" while on stage, your show will be cursed. In high school, I performed in the ensemble of Les Miserables (yes, we did this in high school and it was amazing). Someone accidentally uttered that word and the next day, one of the carts being wheeled onto stage ran over a young man's foot, breaking his toe. It was understood that we had been cursed because of the decision to say "Macbeth" and no one even dared to think the word for the rest of the show.

Theatre kids (and even adults) take this curse very seriously, even though in the back of their minds, there's some voice that tells them how absurd it is to believe such a thing. And this is the plague of television writers, too: the vast majority of them don't believe that the Moonlighting Curse is an actual real thing.

... But at the same time, maybe they believe in it a teeny bit. Enough to dictate how they write their romantic pairings.

Image result for drama drama drama gif

BABY MAMA DRAMA, UNNECESSARY FIGHTING, AND SCANDALS — HOW NOT TO WRITE YOUR FICTIONAL COUPLE IN A FEW EASY STEPS


Okay, so now that we've discussed what the Moonlighting Curse is (and how it's not actually a real thing at all, just a long-held superstition that even the creator of the show denounces the validity of), let's talk about how it impacts the shows that we love dearly. First, let's talk about how the fear of this curse impacts the writing of "will-they-won't-they" pairings when the writers are finally brave enough to get the characters together. We'll pull some pop culture examples for this one, so settle in and listen to me ramble about how I watch far too much television, won't you?

I was thinking about the Moonlighting Curse as I wrote this week's (bitter) review of Arrow. The writers were brave and bold at the end of last season by not only putting hero/vigilante/eventual Green Arrow Oliver Queen (Stephen Amell) and technical genius and fan-favorite Felicity Smoak (Emily Bett Rickards) together after a few years of tip-toeing around commitment, but also by literally sending the pair off into the sunset. At the start of season, Oliver and Felicity were experiencing domestic bliss — brunches, farmer's markets, souffles, and the like — having given up their life of hunting and catching bad guys in favor of a simpler existence. But when the pair returned to Starling City in the season premiere, the writers began to fear that writing the pairing outside of a comfy, cozy life would become stale for the viewers. (I assume this is what happened, because nothing about the rest of the season makes much sense anymore.)

I said in my Arrow review something that I will repeat verbatim here. I think it's worth reading for everyone who wants to become a television writer or is currently a television writer. Are you leaned in close enough? Good, because I'm going to shout this anyway:

Here's a novel concept: if television writers spent time figuring out what made their characters interesting and then wrote THAT [...] we certainly wouldn't need to fear a stupid "curse."

When writers make the bold decision to put their "will-they-won't-they" tension-filled couples together, I believe that on some level (either conscious or subconscious), they begin to frantically worry that the couple being together won't be enough for the audience. On one hand, I can understand their dilemma — sometimes, the very thing we champion for and yell that we want becomes a lot less interesting once we have it in our hands. But this way of thinking, while understandable on some level, is not a reason to interject unnecessary drama just for the sake of having drama. Television audiences are intelligent. We follow character arcs and journeys for a reason. This is the stuff that speaks to us and moves us. We are not petulant children, begging for dessert before dinner — we don't ask for couples to get together because we want to see a repeat of what they went through to become established. THAT is the fun of the "will-they-won't-they," after all.

We don't want writers to repeat that same drama-filled path that led us to our favorite couple getting together. We want the kind of drama that develops organically from the now-established pairing that we didn't get before.


So how does this apply to Arrow, you ask? Well, the writers decided that this season — instead of organically developing something that would happen and would be in-character for both Oliver and Felicity — they would introduce a "secret child" storyline. It's a trope as old as time itself, and — for all of that time it has been around — is generally loathed by audiences. We roll our eyes, because this is not the kind of drama we care about. This is soapy drama for the sake of drama. Moreover, it's EASY drama. It's low-hanging fruit. It's so overwrought and overdone that we have stopped responding to it with anything other than knee-jerk abhorrence. The problem though isn't inherently tied to the trope (though it is problematic), but in the way that this "drama" regressed Oliver. Oliver, a character who had immense flaws and problems last year and was just becoming a more well-rounded, progressed character this season.

I have a lot of hatred for this storyline not because it drives a completely absurd and frankly stupid wedge between a pairing that would have been way more interesting had their drama developed organically. No, I hate it because the problem with the fear of the Moonlighting Curse is that it causes writers to do really, really dumb things that only end up hurting their shows in the long-run. And these things? The writers then attribute the show's problems or lack of critical acclaim to the last bold move it made. And that is — you've guessed it! — the choice to put a couple together.

New Girl had similar problems when it decided to put the idealistic and bright Jessica Day (Zooey Deschanel) and lovable slacker Nick Miller (Jake Johnson) together. The two kissed at the end of "Cooler" — one of the most highly-praised episodes of the series. In a bold move, the series finally decided to act upon the tension that had been present between these characters since day one. Much like on Arrow, it became apparent that the actors had a kind of chemistry and spark that lit up the screen. And New Girl's second season — everything after "Cooler," really — was highly praised by fans and critics alike.

But then something happened: season three, specifically. With Nick and Jess as an established couple, New Girl began to teeter in both ratings and critical acclaim. It was losing its magic, in the eyes of the audience, and the show (and viewers) unfairly attributed it to Nick and Jess getting together. So the show broke the two up, and the show has been on an upswing since. Now, I don't think that Nick and Jess getting together ruined the show. At all. The series' regression of Schmidt and writing of his villainous arc did. Separating Nick and Jess' stories from the loft did. The show not knowing how to utilize Winston well did. Just as Moonlighting wasn't axed because of its two characters consummating a relationship, New Girl didn't falter because of the main characters' relationship.


And yet, it doesn't really matter, right? It doesn't matter WHY a show fails, just as long as writers and audiences have something to easily pinpoint and blame. But what they don't realize is the fact that their inability to accurately pinpoint an issue is the very thing causing their show to slide and falter. It's not Oliver/Felicity that is killing Arrow — it's the fear the writers have that simply writing Oliver and Felicity as they are won't be enough. It wasn't Nick/Jess that doomed New Girl's third season — it was their inability to properly integrate them into the show that did.

The danger in the Moonlighting Curse is that it is not real, but it is often treated like it is.

There are numerous more instances I could talk about in regards to how writers believe that putting "will-they-won't-they" pairings together will doom their shows. But let me just take a moment to talk about an example of how this worked and worked well for one particular show: Parks and Recreation.

On Parks and Recreation, NBC's hit gem, overachieving Leslie Knope (Amy Poehler) and adorably geeky accountant Ben Wyatt (Adam Scott) had a "will-they-won't-they" relationship, culminating in the two dating briefly before they realized they couldn't be together. But when the show put the two characters together again shortly thereafter, there was no question in showrunner Mike Schur's mind: they were going to stay together forever. The characters married and that was it.

Did the show ever have Ben cheat on Leslie? No way. Did Leslie ever lie to Ben and keep a secret from him? Nope! In fact, whenever these two characters endured trying situations or potential job offers, they faced their issues together. Ben always defended Leslie and Leslie always supported Ben. They fought sometimes and they didn't always see eye-to-eye. Ben would have to talk Leslie down if she was being too overzealous, and Leslie would have to liven Ben up when he needed encouragement. Ben and Leslie are one of television's most beloved pairings, and I believe that the reason is because they are flawed but entirely real.

The Parks and Recreation writers never felt the need to throw unnecessary drama or scandal into the Ben/Leslie romance, because they realized something fundamental — their characters were more than enough! Ben and Leslie are each such nuanced, funny, wonderful, entertaining characters. Why would the writes even need to think about driving a wedge between them? There was never a need. The writers of the show remained true to their characters and didn't worry about some silly "curse" being cast over them. They were confident in who they created their characters to be, and more confident in their audience's love for them.

There was no fear. And THAT is why the show remained such a success.


CAN'T (WRITE) ME LOVE


Now that I've talked a little bit about some shows that have incorrectly deduced that putting their own characters together and letting them just BE won't engage audiences, let me talk about the other end of the spectrum here for a moment. I'm going to now talk about how the Moonlighting Curse can impact a television writer's decision to write romance — namely by not writing it at all.

That's actually a tad misleading though. I think you would be  hard-pressed to find a show on television these days that didn't have a romantic element to it, even if the romance isn't between the two main characters. Romance is simply a part of life and to remove it from a show altogether is to remove something fundamentally human from your show. What I'm actually going to talk about his how the Moonlighting Curse causes writers to get trigger-shy when it comes to writing "will-they-won't-they" pairings. I actually wrote a lot about this in another piece I did, and I'll try not to repeat the concepts I outlined there too much, but I do want to provide examples of this problem as well.

Because it really is a problem. Shows that know they have a "will-they-won't-they" pairing on them and refuse to write that pairing truthfully and fairly often garner just as much backlash from critics and fans as shows that write the pairings with soapy drama interjected (i.e., the problematic writing in the shows I noted above). The problem, as I hopefully explained earlier, isn't even the acclaim. It's the matter of not remaining truthful to the characters the show has created.

Let's look at two specific examples of this. First, the case of Community. I've talked about this show extensively enough as it is, so I'll just highlight the problem with the show not getting its snarky former lawyer Jeff Winger (Joel McHale) and perky, overachieving perfectionist Annie Edison (Alison Brie) together during its run. For a sitcom that tackled everything from paintball homages to claymation episodes and a "clip show" created entirely of new scenes, Community had one giant stumbling block — its inability to write romance.


A lot of this stemmed from the imbalanced writing staff (over the years, the staff went from about a 50% male/female split to a sad 95/5% split in the final years, with the majority being — of course — men), and a lot was because of emotional issues the creator Dan Harmon had. Hailed as a creative genius, it's pretty clear that Harmon had a lot of romantic problems of his own which translated to the screen. He firmly believed that romance killed comedy and that it was far better to have a show in which he teased romance but never followed through.

Such was the case of Jeff and Annie, a pairing divided by an age gap but brimming with chemistry. Jeff's love interest was originally supposed to be the blonde-haired activist Britta Perry (Gillian Jacobs), but when chemistry between Joel McHale and Alison Brie sizzled, the show recognized the potential it had. As you might guess, the Moonlighting Curse gripped hold of the writers' room, and strangled them. The worst part about the fear of this curse was that it caused Community's writers to often neither really progress nor really regress Jeff and Annie. They simply remained stagnant... all the while being teased to the audience.

Harmon and his writers loved to bait and switch the viewers, especially those who loved Jeff/Annie romantically. For every scene with a touch or a glance or a sweet line of dialogue, there was another where a character pointed out the characters' age gap, or where something along the lines of "creepy" would be mentioned or Jeff/Britta's romantic history brought up. In being noncommittal, Community ended up dooming itself in the romance department.

Similarly, Suits' inability (or unwillingness, perhaps) to commit to a romance between smooth-talking lawyer Harvey Specter (Gabriel Macht) and sassy, whip-smart legal secretary Donna Paulsen (Sarah Rafferty) is causing issues for the show. Recently, Gabriel Macht was interviewed and noted that he believes relationships between main characters on television shows should not happen. His argument was one that seemed to stem from the long-held fear of this "curse" — that the fun and magic is in the chase, not in the relationship.

And over the course of five years, the show has progressed with Harvey/Donna, only to regress the following episode. This, of course, is slowly strangling the character development of the two characters. The fear of the Moonlighting Curse is a thing that can take hold of and choke the show — there is no doubt about it. And so, out of fear of writing a relationship "wrong" or losing viewers because of committing to one pairing over another, some shows like Suits and Community choose secret option #3 instead and forgo writing romance altogether... but keep the spark of the "will-they-won't-they" alive by never fully taking a plunge.

Though that seems like a "safer" bet, it's actually more dangerous than the option I presented earlier of writing a pairing with unnecessary drama. For all of the faults of Arrow's baby mama drama storyline this season (and boy, are they numerous) in regards to Oliver/Felicity, I can at least acknowledge the fact that the show was bold enough to put the two together early in the series' run. The same holds true for New Girl and every other show that commits to a pairing, in spite of rocky writing.

   

Shows that refuse to commit either way are simply lukewarm. And the problem with lukewarm pairings is that the audience KNOWS they are lukewarm. Frustration mounts and anger builds as characters seem to do erratic things from episode to episode. In this season of Suits, Harvey told Donna that he loved her, tried to take it back, made heart-eyes at her episodes later, and then — just two episodes ago — talked about being in love with another woman. If it doesn't seem like those moments connect, it's because they don't. They're not a cohesive story, and in order to write romance well, there has to be some semblance of a projected movement or direction. When stories become aimless — when shows fear committing to romantic pairings — they doom themselves.

But at least in this case, the shows can't blame romance for their failures, right?

WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE?


There are so many shows on television that I watch these days, in general, and so many that I witness falling into these traps. The 100 has written Bellamy and Clarke as potential love interests, but waffles between love triangles (and squares) so often, that it doesn't want to firmly place itself in anything yet. That's proving to be problematic, as conflicts between characters are being written simply to drive wedges between them, while the character development suffers at the hands of such storylines (I am looking at you, people who are writing Bellamy Blake this season). While it might seem harmless to have a scene of Clarke and Bellamy making heart-eyes at one another, and while shippers eat this kind of stuff up on Twitter and Tumblr, when the dust settles and the next episode features a Clarke/Lexa romantic moment, it's easy to understand why viewers are frustrated. Pandering to shippers never ends well, and even if The 100 doesn't want to commit to a romantic pairing at this moment, it should at least try to remain true to its characterization. Having Clarke go from hating Lexa in one episode to falling for her the next isn't character progression — it's bending a character to fit the story a writer wants to tell, rather than let the character dictate the story.

On The Blacklist, it's clear that Donald Ressler and Elizabeth Keen have chemistry, but the allure of creating a love triangle was too strong to pass up. Characterization of Liz was sacrificed for the sake of drama. Two steps forward and two steps back seems to be the song Scorpion is playing when it comes to Walter and Paige's relationship, and the show is unsure whether or not it needs to commit or not. The dance — while not falling directly into either of these categories right now — is hanging in the balance, and needs to find some sort of progression soon, lest it become stale and trite. (Same thing on Jane the Virgin, which — thankfully — decided to add a new love interest to the mix in order to prevent the triangle element from recurring. Again.)

Romance isn't easy to write. It's difficult to find the balance between humor and heart in comedies, and it's easy to step over the line and into melodrama and soapy on dramas. But as we noted, it is very rarely the fault of a ship that dooms a show, and is — more often than not — the fault of writers themselves. Audiences must remember, however, that even the most well-written shows are prone to missteps. We should not be so bold as to demand something that a show cannot deliver, and we should not be disappointed when the "will-they-won't-they" tension is resolved.

Instead, we should not see the Moonlighting Curse as a curse at all. We should see it as an opportunity — a chance to right the wrongs of generations of television series before us. We should recognize it for what it is: a false belief that peppers our culture and causes writers to do foolish things in the name of preserving their show for as long as possible.

If we can continue to debunk the curse in writers' rooms and critical circles, perhaps it can be put to rest once and for all.

close call relief sarah chalke phew sweet relief

Tuesday, January 26, 2016

Team Snowflakes vs. Team Flower Petals: The Ships of 'Jane the Virgin' [Contributor: Connie]


Jane the Virgin is back from winter hiatus! In order to celebrate, I have decided to explore the two main ships on the show in terms of their usual motifs: Jane/Michael as Team Snowflakes and Jane/Rafael as Team Flower Petals. Of course, Team Jane wins above all, but Michael and Rafael both represent great (if flawed) men, who love Jane and want the best for her.

But their relationships look very different and have different attractions — both for Jane and for us audience members. The choice of motif is actually very indicative of each relationship — both for better and for worse — so let’s discuss!

TEAM SNOWFLAKES 


Jane and Michael have had many romantic moment under falling “snowflakes,” most notably the ceiling dust when they first meet and the fake snow at the Marbella when they reunite for their epic “let’s get back together” kiss. Snowflakes, of course, symbolize winter — which is the perfect season to represent Jane and Michael’s relationship. Winter represents steadiness, quiet, and purity.

Its use is often similar to the color white, which is often used to denote purity, light, and innocence. See Shakespeare’s use in Cymbeline, for instance, "I thought her as chaste as unsunned snow." 

Snow, especially the first snow, sometimes feels like magic; the world becomes quiet and beautiful. (I live in New York where we just had the second biggest snowstorm in the city’s history, and the quietness of the storm as it raged indeed felt like magic.)

Michael is just as steadfast, always quietly supporting Jane, and of course, respecting her desire for chastity. Michael is often a soft blanket of snow, calming Jane’s anxieties. Winter means staying at home, or being snowed in, and Michael is known for being very close with the other Villanueva women. He is very comfortable in their house. He is the person you cuddle with on the couch and watch the Netflix Yule Log with — the person who you could be with forever.

However, winter is cold and snow can go from peaceful and fun to a dangerous blizzard very quickly. Jane the Virgin is set in Miami, a city where snow is nearly impossible. Winter ends and snow eventually thaws. Jane’s love for Michael is overtaken by her attraction to Rafael, which burns just a little hotter...

TEAM FLOWER PETALS 


Jane and Rafael represent springtime. Their iconic first kiss featured falling cherry blossoms swirling around them. Springtime and flowers represent passion, rebirth, and warmth. Spring is outdoor adventure, sunshine, and growth. The intensity and liveliness of the cherry blossom gives the warrant for anyone to dream and hope for big things in the future and to be optimistic. 

Spring represents first love. Rafael solidified that position when 19-year-old Jane fell for him all those years ago. Jane and Rafael’s relationship is one of twirly, dancing, rapping dates — it is energetic. Just like flowers opening up in bloom, Jane encourages Rafael to open up to his emotions. Springtime is constantly changing, nature and creatures are growing very fast, just like Jane and Raf’s relationship. Spring also represents fertility, birth, and babies. No need to break that one down.

Jane and Rafael’s passion for one another often tests her vow of chastity; without Michael's cool blanket of snow to calm her, Jane lets her equally fiery temper match Rafael's and they erupt at one another. Just like snow can melt, flowers wilt and die, spring soon burns too hot and becomes a raging summer.

Both relationships have their magical qualities — people love winter and spring for different reasons. This is why it is so hard for Jane and many fans to choose which guy is the best for her. Yet both have their downfalls as well, the reasons why they do not last long. Placed against the other, Jane has something she needs from one relationship that the other does not provide. She both needs Michael’s peacefulness to calm her anxieties, but she needs Rafael’s passion to push her to experiences that enhance her story (as a woman and as a writer).

We do not yet know which direction the show will decide on, but with the season two mid-winter return, it seems we are expecting a decent amount of snow. Bundle up, Team Flower Petals!

Tuesday, December 29, 2015

11 of the Best Ship Moments in 2015


Relationships are complicated.

At least, that’s what Jeff Winger told Annie Edison years ago on the NBC sitcom, Community. And he’s right. Relationships aren’t easy and sometimes they’re confusing and messy. Television relationships are no exception. 2015 has proven to be a really great year for some television couples as they exchanged “I love you’s” and first kisses, and a not-so-great year for others, amidst break-ups and kept secrets.

For better or for worse, television writers have learned to harness the power of romantic relationships on dramas and comedies. Relationships between characters are foundations on which the shows themselves are built, after all. So it makes sense, then, that “shippers” are so prominent among fandoms. Often given a bad reputation or dismissed by creators and critics, these people — myself included — find themselves invested in romantic relationships in their favorite shows. And, having been around fandom for as long as I have, I’ve discovered that shippers are some of the most creative and inventive people. They’re invested in character arcs and stories more than a casual viewer or a fan. They then make the show their own — someone’s created work becomes the very thing that spurs them on toward creativity, too. Shippers form communities, create fan art and videos, and write fanfiction. It’s mind-boggling to me, in the best way possible, that showrunners have this often unknown impact on the people who watch what they create.

So, as the end of the year approaches, I am here to break down eleven of the best “ship” moments of 2015. Some of these are aww-inducing, some might surprise you, and some are on the list because of how gut-wrenching they are. So sit back, grab some chocolate (and maybe wine) and relish in my favorite shippy moments of this year!



11. The Rafael/Jane time jump (Jane the Virgin)

Okay, all drama with Michael/Jane and Rafael/Jane aside, one of the smartest and best things that Jane the Virgin did this year was present a time jump in a believable way. Television shows that center — either in part or in full — around growing children often encounter problems because... well, kids grow up between the time that it takes to shoot a television show. So this CW comedy chose to take one episode and jump forward in time. This allowed us to see Mateo grow, but also to see Rafael and Jane’s relationship grow, too.

These two have always had a complex relationship (made more complex by the whole baby daddy thing), but “Chapter Twenty-Eight” was amazing and one of my absolute favorite Rafael/Jane moments of 2015. Because in allowing time to pass, we got to see Jane’s heart heal from her relationship with Michael in a believable way (that would have taken weeks or months had the show stuck to its initial real-time format). We saw Rafael date someone else, too, and I think that was important. He dated someone who wasn’t Petra — conniving and brilliantly evil — which is something that was important. And we got the chance to see both characters naturally progress and move back toward one another. So by the time Rafael asks Jane out on a date at the end of the episode, we all believe she’s ready. (And we swoon. Or is that just me?)

I am first and foremost #TeamJane, but if I was forced to choose between snowflakes and flower petals, it would be #TeamFlowerPetals all the way. I love the way that Rafael and Jane naturally clash. Their relationship is full of bumps, but that’s what makes it so believable and so wonderful. They have amazing chemistry together and they’re a family. I can’t quite explain it any other way than that.



10. The “Love is Strange” duet (Galavant)

I absolutely and positively love Galavant. If you haven’t checked out this musical comedy, you really need to. In my review of the pilot I described it this way: “If Monty Python's Spamalot and Mel Brooks' Robin Hood: Men in Tights had an illegitimate child, it would be named Galavant.”

I still stand by that, honestly.

Apart from being excited that the show was miraculously renewed for a second season, looking back on this show’s freshman year has me excited. One of my absolute favorite moments was the “Love is Strange” duet between Galavant and Isabella. The best thing that this series does — among many things — is flip tropes on their heads. Madalena, the seemingly innocent maiden, turns out to be scheming and conniving and delightfully evil. Similarly, Isabella turns out to be the kind of kick-butt and yet emotionally vulnerable heroine and love interest that we all needed. And though Galavant and Isabella sing a love song to one another, this song involves talking about how weird and gross and strange love is. What a wonderfully inverted ballad trope, right?

The realistic picture of love that they paint stands in contrast to the fairytale-esque structure of the show and I absolutely love it. If you don’t swoon while listening to Joshua Sasse sing, then you might just be a robot. Galavant/Isabella forever, you guys.



9. Sheldon and Amy... well, you know. (The Big Bang Theory)

I watch The Big Bang Theory whenever I can. Most weeks, I’ll watch it On Demand after I’ve worked out on a Saturday. Sometimes I forget that new episodes have aired and have to have a mini-binge. The show gets a lot of flak because of the fact that it’s a multi-camera comedy and often its portrayal of nerd culture can be pretty one-dimensional. But what I’ve seen the show do in recent years is something pretty impressive — it’s taken to focusing on developing its main characters and really earning the emotional moments. Some of the most impressive areas of growth have come from the character of Sheldon Cooper, especially in his relationship with Amy.

Recently, one of the most important episodes of the show has aired — the episode in which Sheldon and Amy sleep together for the first time. And though the framing of that was hilarious (the cutaways to Raj, Leonard, Howard, and Wil Wheaton in the theater was so great), the moment that really struck me and earned these two a spot on my list was the subtle way that Jim Parsons softened Sheldon. When Amy emerges in her nightgown, the look on Sheldon’s face is so impossibly sweet. You can see him soften and relax into a loving glance — something we are unaccustomed to seeing. Amy’s nervousness isn’t played for laughs, and neither is Sheldon’s response to her. The two genuinely love one another and their moments in that scene were earnest, tender, and completely lovely.



8. Ben and Leslie’s unwavering support for one another (Parks and Recreation)

I’ll never stop talking about how sad I am that Parks and Recreation has ended. But what I will say is that I was never disappointed in the way they handled Ben and Leslie’s romance. The show always strove to portray the unwavering love and support the two had for each other and their relationship, and when the show jumped forward in its final season — no matter how many years — it maintained that. Ben was always willing to stand aside to let Leslie shine, and she was willing to do the exact same. Both made sacrifices in their relationship and truly, their marriage and love was one of equality.

I always discuss the fact that Ben and Leslie’s romance is “relationship goals”... because that romance IS. It was a complete and true partnership, in every sense of the word. Whether he was letting her talk during “Pie-Mary,” or she was supporting him years down the line — through it all, these two communicated about their feelings and struggled, always put one another first, and made sure to carve out time no matter what to express how much they loved one another. I cannot think of a better example of a television ship than these two.



7. Toby and Happy let each other in and kiss (Scorpion)

Scorpion is one of the best shows on television that you’re not watching. You probably dismissed it as a procedural. Maybe you even presumed it was just CSI-lite. You would be wrong. Though Scorpion’s first season was good, it had a few bumps and bruises. But this second season is the strongest yet of the series and the writing has never been better. Not only are there physical stakes for the things our characters are doing, but emotional ones as well.

Toby and Happy have always had this kind of weird relationship — she throws up every wall and defense she can, and he tries to constantly pursue her. In fact, Toby is pretty relentless in the way that he cares about Happy. But he does care. He doesn’t pursue her because he’s hopeful that he can gain something in return, necessarily — he pursues her because he knows she deserves better than she allows herself to believe or have. She understands him and he knows why she wants to keep him at bay. But during this season of Scorpion, these two crazy kids have – for a few, select moments – put their guards down. One such moment happened in the midseason finale, in which Happy was close to drowning. After the ordeal (and the fact that, not too many episodes prior, Toby technically died for a minute or two) and reminders of Megan, Happy’s outlook on her relationship with Toby shifted slightly. And she told him to kiss her.

Apart from the fact that that was one heck of a kiss, the kiss lands on my favorite ship moments of the year because it signaled an active step for Happy. Usually Toby pursues, but it was Happy who called the shots this time around. And it was beautiful. (Runner-up moment? When Toby and Happy slow-danced during “The Old College Try” because HOW CUTE WAS THAT?)



6. Bellamy will not let Clarke be alone (The 100)

Amidst a show with seemingly thirteen billion different shipping options (Clarke/Lexa, Bellamy/Clarke, Lincoln/Octavia, Kane/Abby, etc. etc.), I found myself drawn to Bellamy/Clarke — or, as the kids call them “Bellarke” — during 2015. There is something so subtle and yet powerful about the fact that these two characters began as adversaries and, by the end of the second season, became partners in every sense of the word. One of the most powerful ship moments for me of this past year was Bellamy’s refusal to let Clarke be alone.

I love Clarke because she’s a complex, damaged character who has been forced to make really difficult decisions in order to save her people. And really, I love that Clarke is a character who HAS a “people.” She was always a natural-born leader, because of her desire to care for others and keep them safe. Her instinct to protect her own often leads her down some dark and difficult roads, especially this past year. And when she has no choice than to kill those living in Mount Weather in an act of mass genocide (this is a show on The CW, you guys, and is darker than some of the stuff on HBO), she prepares to do it alone. She prepares to bear the consequences of the act on her shoulders. Clarke braces to feel the weight of hundreds, thousands of souls crushing down on her.

But then, Bellamy places his hand over hers. And they make this decision together. It’s so important to me that Bellamy does this, because it symbolizes the fact that he never wants Clarke to feel like she is alone. He cares about her. Bellamy did so reluctantly, at first — he didn’t want to like the girl whom he sardonically called “princess.” He wanted to hate her. But he couldn’t.

Bellamy loves Clarke. It’s hard to argue that, given their final exchange at the end of the season. Clarke wants to leave Camp Jaha, because the weight of what she had to do is too much to handle. It’s crushing her. But gently, Bellamy tells her that he placed his hand over hers in Mount Weather for a reason. He did it so she would know he is always there for her – she is not, nor will she ever be, alone. And Bellamy extends forgiveness to her, in a beautiful (and sad) parallel to what Clarke did for him during “Day Trip.” He searches her face and she hugs him tightly, but she leaves all the same.

I know it’s going to be a rough road for my Bellarke-loving heart in season three, but I’m glad that 2015 helped establish their dynamic and I’m hopeful that next year will build upon it.



5. Jeff and Annie kiss goodbye (Community)

Jeff and Annie are probably my biggest love affair over the past few years. Their dynamic is so complex and their relationship so difficult to comprehend in some ways, and yet so impossibly simple in others. The fact of the matter is that Jeff Winger fell in love with a bright, young, idealistic woman and that changed him from the inside out. His heart softened. His priorities shifted. He began to care about things and people he never assumed he would. He didn’t always express it correctly, but he always has had a soft spot for Annie. She’s been his partner and his rock and his best friend in a lot of ways for years.

And when faced with the cold fact that Annie would be leaving him to take an internship across the country, Jeff began to crumble. The man who scoffed at the very notion of settling down and balked at the idea of marriage years ago daydreams in the series finale about a life with Annie – a home with her, really. He daydreams about building a family and having a life. He daydreams about happiness. Throughout their relationship, Jeff was always the more emotionally distanced. Annie gave up, after a few failed attempts, at trying to read Jeff’s mind and his signals. She eventually stopped dwelling too much on how jealous he got of other guys, and focused on her career and her schooling. But she was always enamored by him, and I believe she loved him, too.

So when she enters the study room to check and ensure Jeff is okay, he confesses that he’s not. He wishes he could turn back time and be exactly where Annie is at that moment — ready to head off into the world, with years stretched ahead of him. And Annie wishes for more time — for more wisdom and years that Jeff has and she doesn’t. When it’s time to come face-to-face with those struggles, Jeff becomes more honest than he was in six years of knowing Annie. He tells her that he has tried to let her go, but that his heart still wants her. So Annie... tells him to kiss her goodbye.

It’s probably not a goodbye kiss, because these two crazy kids would be... well, crazy, to not see one another again. It’s a kiss with a promise, though — tender and sweet and so unlike the ones they had years ago. Because now Jeff knows he loves Annie, and it changes how he behaves. Instead of being the selfish jerk who manipulated others in the pilot, in the series finale Jeff Winger became the man who was so selfless that he let the woman he loved most in the world go, knowing that it would hurt him, but create opportunities and happiness for her. In the words of the Internet: “feels.”



4. Oliver's goodbye to Felicity (Arrow)

I would talk about the soufflé faux-engagement or the real engagement, or the suburban rom-com that Oliver and Felicity found themselves in at the beginning of this season. I could even discuss their adorable domestic bliss after they returned to Star(ling) City. I might even be tempted to talk about their first time together in Nanda Parbat.

But I’m actually not going to. Instead, I’m going to talk about something reminiscent of what I will discuss with Captain Swan — I’m going to talk about pain. In spite of the rocky, uneven, and occasional downright horrible writing of the third season of Arrow, there were some bright spots for the show in 2015. A lot of them took place in the current season, but the most important one to me took place during “The Fallen,” in which Oliver bade Felicity goodbye. Apart from being absolutely gut-wrenching acting from Stephen Amell and Emily Bett Rickards, this scene was so important to me and — to be quite honest — much preferred over the sex scene itself.

Because this is the moment in which Oliver and Felicity are at their most honest and vulnerable. She begins to cry at the thought of leaving him, and he confesses to her that the only way he can make it through being in Nanda Parbat is if he knows she is out there, happy. You can almost feel the unspoken words lingering in Felicity’s head – that she cannot be happy without HIM beside her — but she doesn’t utter them. Instead, the music swells and the two kiss, vowing to not say goodbye this time, since it has become their “thing” to do. This moment is so tender and so intimate that it almost makes you want to look away. You feel like you’re invading this quiet, love-wrought moment.

It’s not just the fact that they have to say goodbye that made this scene so sad and ultimately so moving for me. It’s the fact that we have to watch Oliver watch Felicity walking away. Unlike the many times she has walked away from him before, this time was not because she wanted to, or was angry — it was because she had to. This moment is so beautiful, so sad, and the contrast of the hopelessness in the darkness and the hopefulness of the light that frames it is what makes it the best Oliver/Felicity moment of the year for me.



3. Emma has to kill Hook (Once Upon A Time)

Though it might seem odd for me to choose this heartbreaking moment as the best ship moment for Hook and Emma of 2015, I choose it because it was the most powerful acting I’ve seen from Colin O’Donoghue and Jennifer Morrison. Captain Swan, as they have been dubbed by fans, has gone through a lot the past year. Emma turned into the Dark One, we relished in flashbacks, and then Hook was revealed to have been brought back from the brink of death by Emma, cursing him to also become the Dark One. When it became clear that the only way to save Storybrooke and the people he loved was to die at Emma’s hand, Hook stared death boldly in the face. But, most importantly, he stared into the eyes of his beloved, too.

The complete and utter anguish of that scene is slightly undercut by the complete and utter love that is felt as Emma holds Hook and sobs over his broken body. Hook and Emma have gone through a lot together — they were each so used to constructing walls and forcing people out that when they finally let one another in, it was really important that they did so. We’ve seen the truth, too, that these two will never give up on one another and never stop fighting for one another either.

Hope may seem lost now that Hook has died, but make no mistake about it: Emma doesn’t see that as a roadblock. She will rescue the man she loves. Because, after all: “Death cannot stop true love. All it can do is delay it for a while.”

   

2. Schmidt proposes to Cece (New Girl)

Guys, I did not think that I would become as invested in Schmidt and Cece’s relationship as I was this year. The problem that New Girl had in the third season was that the decision to have Schmidt cheat on Elizabeth and Cece ultimately made him a villain. I’ve always — literally, since the pilot episode — been a shipper of Nick and Jess, and though they had some great moments this season (the one in “Oregon,” and “Clean Break”), it is Schmidt/Cece that stole my heart. The writing of Schmidt this year was so impeccable. He was redeemed from a womanizing character into one who genuinely and truly cared about Cece as a friend, first and foremost. I believed their friendship this year, wholeheartedly, and “The Crawl” and “Oregon” were both great examples of the lengths Schmidt was willing to go to for Cece without anything being in it for him.

And for most of this season, Schmidt was either preoccupied with Fawn or Cece with her studies. But these two never stopped loving one another. That love was always there, bubbling just beneath the surface. But they knew they had to get their lives back in order as individuals before there could ever be hope for them again, romantically. I think that both always knew that if they were to give their relationship a second (third?) chance, it would be permanent. The way that Max Greenfield and Hannah Simone play these characters with such earnestness and endearment toward one another is so lovely to watch unfold. They really went above and beyond this season to unearth subtleties in these characters, which makes me even more excited to watch their engagement and wedding next season.

Schmidt’s proposal to Cece made me cry. It was his truthfulness and devotion, coupled with Cece’s quiet confession of love that was so captivating. The choice for the show to integrate the not-really-flashback-flashback was the absolute perfect decision and I’m so glad that the writers did that. And just like that, the words: “Girl, will you marry me?” made me burst out into tears and cheers. Thank you, New Girl, for making me fall in love with Schmidt/Cece this year. Good job.

   

1. Harvey tells Donna that he loves her (Suits)

Harvey and Donna’s relationship is so important to me.

They absolutely and truly love one another, that it’s impossible to deny that fact. Every character on this series — no, seriously, every character from major to guest-starring attorneys — has pointed out the fact that Harvey and Donna love one another. And even though I have always been a fan of their flirting, bantering dynamic and their unwavering loyalty to one another, it was this year that really pushed me over the edge into full-fledged Harvey/Donna shipper territory. It might have a little something to do with the “I love you” that Harvey uttered to Donna.

When it seemed like all hope was lost and that Donna might go to jail for something she did, Harvey stepped in and did everything within (and outside of) his power to keep Donna safe. He made sure to tell everyone, too, that this case? It was different. Because it was about her. We saw a side of Harvey Specter that we are unaccustomed to seeing. We saw him unhinged. When he thought that Donna might actually go to jail and believed he had no way to stop that, Donna confronted him about his lack of empathy toward her. His demeanor had been icy and distanced, while Louis was offering support and embraces. It was then that Harvey admitted that the thought of Donna going to prison made him want to drop to his knees. If she was gone? That would cripple him. Later on, Harvey admitted that if other people lose faith in him, it doesn’t matter. All that matters is what SHE thinks about him and feels for him. This was completely uncharted territory for Harvey and Donna — both, none more than Harvey, are typically emotionally guarded given their professional relationship and personal history. Harvey let his guard down for the first time in forever with Donna — completely down — and the softness and quietness with which he uttered words of affirmation and care toward Donna was so powerful that it made me catch my breath.

And then, just as Harvey is leaving, Donna asks him “why?” It’s a question that she genuinely asks, without any sort of knowledge of what he might say. So when Harvey says: “You know I love you Donna,” in return, the only thing that registers on her face is shock. She, for the first time in forever, did not expect something like that to happen. But when Donna confronts Harvey about what he said, he — in typical fashion — throws back up his walls and tries to back out of his feelings. Instead of talking through them, he lies and denies. And that’s when Donna hits her breaking point. Because for all of their guarded feelings and hidden emotions, Harvey was always honest with her. Honesty is something Donna Paulsen values above all other things.

When Harvey refused to even talk through his feelings, Donna realized that it was time to start protecting her own for once. She had spent so much time protecting Harvey, so much time excusing his emotional distance, that I think she lost herself and the validity of her own feelings in that denial. And in what has to be one of the most heartbreaking things in 2015, Donna tells Harvey that she loves him... and that she is working for Louis. He pleads with her to stay, and she turns and walks away instead. For as much as she loves him, Donna realized she needed to put her own well-being first for once. And Harvey, as a result, crumbled under anxiety and panic attacks. (Okay, those were due to other things apart from just Donna, but still.)

These two had one of the most important relationships on TV in 2015, and not enough people talk about them. (P.S. Come on, Suits. You cannot use a cover of “The Scientist” over a Harvey/Donna scene. THAT IS WHAT FANVIDEOS ARE FOR AND WHY THEY DESTROY OUR EMOTIONS!)

Did you favorite ships make my cut? What were some of your favorite moments from these and other shows? Hit up the comments below and let me know your thoughts! Until then, happy almost-2016!

Saturday, September 12, 2015

To Be Or Not To Be... A Study of Toxic & Healthy TV Relationships

love life new girl dreams hope

What makes us human is our capacity to love -- to give and receive it. When that happens, relationships form. Whether romantic, platonic, paternal, or otherwise, relationships are complex. They're often messy (in a good way) or downright messy (in the cringing kind of way). But... I don't know. I think that's kind of awesome. I think that it's wonderful that love isn't this simple, cut-and-dry formula that always makes sense to us. I like that sometimes we can't help who we fall in love with. I like that love can be redemptive and it can be as simple as watching television in your pajamas with your best friend or as deep as walking down the aisle to marry the person you want to stand beside forever. Love is awesome in real life. And the emotional components from our real lives carry over into the fictional ones that we see depicted on television.

I really enjoy watching television for plot and writing and characterization. But what I also enjoy is watching television to ship. We all (or most of us, at least) freely admit to shipping being at least part of the reason we enjoy (or don't enjoy) a certain television show. Watching love unfold is fun. It's awesome. It's enjoyable to watch the guy get the girl. We hold our breaths when two characters we ship stand close to one another in a scene. We swoon at the love confessions. And we cheer when they finally kiss.

But sometimes, relationships are portrayed as toxic and aren't necessarily acknowledged as such. Lindsay brilliantly talked about that this past week when she discussed the problem with the romanticism we see in television of men aggressively pursuing women and not taking "no" for an answer. The toxicity that I'm going to discuss today is a bit more subtle than that. It's the recognition that certain ships are toxic because the individuals within the pairing actually make each other worse, not better. And while I was thinking about these relationships, I actually found some pretty solid parallelism between Jeff/Britta on Community and Oliver/Laurel on Arrow. So those are the couples we're going to talk about, plus why other ships with these individuals (Jeff/Annie and Oliver/Felicity) are not toxic.

Disclaimer: If you're a fan of either Jeff/Britta or Oliver/Laurel, stop reading. Like, now. I seriously won't be offended in the slightest. What WILL offend me is someone not reading this disclaimer and then arguing with me in the comments about why these ships are awesome just so they can hear themselves talk.

So let's begin!

Wednesday, September 9, 2015

Feminism vs. The Slow Burn Romance [Guest Poster: Lindsay MacDonald]


You might know Lindsay MacDonald from her work at Tell-Tale TV, her pieces on TV Fanatic, or just that girl who we enjoy live-tweeting re-watches of The 100 with. Lindsay is an exceptional human being, super sweet, and passionate about television (and we got to have tacos with her at San Diego Comic-Con, so we win). 
Here, she's penned a guest post for us about what happens when television couples are written as "slow burns" and become... well, problematic in the way that romance is portrayed. Enjoy her piece and be sure to tweet her and/or comment below to keep the conversation going!

It's the staple of a good television show to tease out a ship, pairing, and/or couple as long as physically possible before finally letting them (finally) come together. The music crescendos, the boy gets the girl, and the fade-to-black slowly takes over your screen. But only, obviously, after a good four seasons of consistent suspense and anxiety. The main purpose behind this practice is, of course, to keep the audience interested and invested in the drama of the will-they-won't-they dynamic that governs all romances.

Some of televisions greatest couples have committed to the slow burn, in fact. Meredith and Derek on Grey's Anatomy. Damon and Elena on The Vampire Diaries. Luke and Lorelai on Gilmore Girls. Plus many, many more!

(No, seriously I could go on forever).

The beauty of the slow burn is that it draws us into the story being told and makes us root for the couple. The drama of a slow burn keeps us hovering on the edge of our seats to see when the couple might finally overcome all of their obstacles to be together. We're all suckers for a happy ending.

But there is a specific brand of slow burn that tends to grate on this feminist's nerves and it goes a little something like this:

Person A, suddenly and instantly infatuated with Person B, makes their feelings known via confession, acts of love, devotion, and whatever usual tomfoolery characters in love tend to participate in. All of which, Person B rebuffs, kindly or not through phrases that resemble: "he's a bad boy," or "she's just a friend," or even "I'm not looking for a relationship right now." These are all quite typical excuses used by Person B.  
Here's the kicker though: Person A still continues to pine and chase and pursue Person B, even after they've been not-so-subtly told to buzz off.

Usually, audiences go gaga over this kind of stuff in slow burn couples and in romance in general. There's something disturbingly alluring, apparently, about a woman who says no when she's really just fighting her deepest desires, or a boy who slowly and steadily becomes convinced that the girl of his dreams has been in front of him the whole time.

But that's typically right when warning bells start going off in my mind.

Because as saucy and spicy as it sounds to watch a man who won't take no for an answer and continues to pursue the woman he cares about, it's also reflective of a mentality that should send most girls -- who are not characters on television shows -- running for the hills. This idea that a woman who says no really just means "try harder" is so very troubling to see portrayed as a sexy, romantic subplot. Any girl who has ever been harassed by a stranger, an ex, or even a trusted friend will tell you that the most terrifying thing in the world is a guy who hears the word "no" and thinks you actually mean "yes" and continues to pursue you. Similarly, someone who pines after you or makes you feel like an awful human being for not giving them a chance romantically is a total buzzkill. If the feelings aren't there or mutual, do you really want to have to convince someone to like you? To see your beloved finally throw their hands up in the air and shout "Ugh fine, you've worn me down. You win!" when you ask them to love you back? That doesn't exactly sound like a solid foundation for long-term relationship if you ask me.

Both of these slow burn examples of characters forcibly turning a "no" in to a "yes" bring into question the topic of consent. And consent is a feminist issue that comes into play for both genders, and across the board. Men and women who say "no" to someone else's advancements deserve the right to be heard and respected by the pursuant individual, and romanticizing their refusal as simply just playing hard-to-get is, at best, irresponsible and at worst, extremely dangerous.

Dangerous because as a society, we are completely and totally inundated with media and its many messages. The books we read, and the movies and television we watch work together to shape our perception of the world -- in both right and wrong ways. And, whether we like it or not, media also shapes acceptable social behavior from the time we are children, up until the time we're old and grey. How many times have you heard a story about a little kid jumping off the roof or another tall structure because he just wanted to emulate Superman and believed that he could?

Obviously the politics of unrequited love and how best to react to it are a little more subtle than jumping off a roof or a building, but the core principle remains the same; we take the stories we see and read about to heart whether it's conscious or not. Therefore, depicting a firm "NO" in a slow burn romance as really a "not yet" is something that is akin to setting a lit match beside a pile of kindling -- extremely dangerous with potentially life-altering consequences as a result.

Now, I'm not talking about wooing, courtship, or even seduction as portrayed in media. Those things are all well and good and normal parts of a healthy romance and they are typically depicted as such. The slow burn of Luke and Lorelai in Gilmore Girls for instance, was a constant dance of two people trying to get the timing right in order to explore their deeper feelings for one another. There was never a moment when Luke sabotaged one of Lorelai's relationships in the hopes that she would one day give him a chance. He never guilt-tripped her for treating him like a friend instead of a viable romantic partner for so many years. Instead, the writers crafted a natural progression of romance and romantic feelings from each side that made their eventual coupling feel organic. Once those feelings were reciprocated on both sides, then the fun and games really got started.

Stealing from the same show, for a moment, we can see the example of a slow burn gone awry if we examine the relationship between Rory and Jess. I know, I know. But set down your pitch forks for one second while I explain a little bit more: Jess arrived in town and developed an instant attraction to Rory based on their shared interests, chemistry, and compatibility. And those are all exceptionally good things to have in a slow burn and in a romantic coupling. But how many times did Rory tell Jess to leave her alone? How many times did she make it clear to him how uncomfortable his interest made her and the many problems it caused between her and her current boyfriend, Dean? And how many times did Jess ignore her pleas to stop because he "knew" that she wanted him, deep down.

Are you seeing any red flags yet?

I'm not condemning the entire relationship between Rory and Jess. I do think it had many wonderful aspects, and well… she did want Jess, deep down. I'm merely pointing out that thousands of fans fell head over heels for the love story between these two, when -- at its core -- it sent the very troubling messages to men and women. Messages that girls will tell a bad boy they don't want him, when really they're secretly longing for him to ignore their refusal. Messages that if a woman shows no interest in you and rejects you, the natural response for men is to try and try and try again because eventually she will relent.

With one or two minor tweaks, and the addition of a creepy cabin in a woods, that story quickly turns into an episode of Criminal Minds.

With all of this said, does this mean that characters on TV can never play hard to get or fight against their burgeoning feelings for someone they know they probably shouldn't (or cannot) be with? Absolutely not! That's just good television, guys: the struggle, the angst, the longing. The key in crafting a slow burn that is pro-consent is in the way that the story is told. In telling the story of a slow burn relationship that evolves naturally, and in avoiding the kind of "relationship" that romanticizes and lauds the unsolicited wearing down of another person. That kind of romance -- the natural, good, pro-consent kind -- shouldn't be as difficult as it is to find sometimes on television, but you might be surprised at how often the second option is chosen by writers because, to them, it's just more alluring and sexy.

Now, here comes the difficult part. It's often hard for fans to see the flaws in their beloved characters and couples. We get so entrenched in the romance and passion of it all that we often forget to look for these delicate details that might cause us to reevaluate what exactly we find so appealing about a ship or a storyline and why. And, more importantly, we don't often think about what we're being told regarding relationships on television and what we -- personally -- have been taught to believe is acceptable in our own lives because of television.

So I've decided to end this little analysis of mine with a challenge. Are you ready? Here it is: Name some of your favorite "TV Slow Burn Romances" of all time in your head. And then take a good, hard look at them while asking yourselves these questions:  Did Person A keep pursuing after they were told to stop? Was person B cajoled or coerced into giving their not-so-romantic love interest a chance? Was your OTP's slow burn depicted in a way that makes you giddy or slightly uncomfortable?

Feel free to sound off in comments below with examples of each kind of slow burn romance: the good and the bad.

Thursday, August 27, 2015

Of Mulder/Scully and the Birth of the "Shipping" Phenomenon [Contributor: Lizzie]


Mulder/Scully - The Truth - mulder-and-scully Screencap


Shipper: short for relationshipper; one who believes there is, was, should, and could be a relationship between two characters in a certain fandom.


IN THE BEGINNING...

The definition above is mostly, for the uninitiated. I’m not even sure there’s a person online right now who needs the term "shipping" described to them, but I decided to play it safe and include it anyway. After all, my mom could be reading this article. And she would probably need the definition.

But the rest of us… we’re clear. We know what shipping is. We’ve probably actively engaged in shipping (or currently "engage," present tense, whatever). We’ve discussed the merits of one ship over another; we’ve written fanfic, created GIF sets, analyzed every little word and/or touch to distraction, and written thousands of words about character motives. And we’ve probably even told our friends -- or maybe our editors -- that they’re wrong to ship a certain pairing (Jenn, I still love you, but Harry/Hermione?!).

Shipping is a part of life. Well, it's a part of fandom life, at least. And something pretty great is that shipping not a rational thing: we don’t always ship two people because the writing is dictating that they become a couple, though that’s a reason. Sometimes, honestly, we ship two characters because of the chemistry. Other times, it’s just purely for the sake of aesthetics – we want the pretty people to get together, dang it! We may even ship two characters because their interactions speak to a part of ourselves and our lives that we keep hidden from the rest of the world.

The point is, there are many reasons to ship one couple or another. I’m not here to discuss, in-depth, those particular reasons or my own preference of ships. I have mine (many, many ships... too many to count, really but hit me up on Twitter if you want to know) and you have yours. You probably won’t change your mind about your ships, and I won’t change mine. And, actually, that doesn’t even really matter.

What matters is this: this whole shipping phenomenon, as we know, it started a little over twenty years ago, because of David Duchovny, Gillian Anderson and a purposely vague relationship between the male and female leads of The X-Files.

The rest, as they say, is TV history.

Now, this isn't to say that Mulder and Scully were the original ship. They were not the first time people looked at two people and said: "I want THOSE two to get together." People have been shipping characters for as long as there have been books, TV, and movies. Heck, I would not be surprised if people shipped Romeo and Juliet in Shakespeare's day. But the actual term and the frenzy associated with it? Well – you can thank fans of The X-Files for that.

ANCIENT HISTORY

In the old days of usenet groups and modems, when fanfiction.net and Tumblr were still pipe dreams, X-Files fans were divided in two groups: those who wanted Mulder and Scully to get together (a.k.a, the relationshippers) and those who wanted the relationship to remain platonic (a.k.a. the noromos). One of those terms stuck, the other one… well, the other one went the way of their desires.

Since this is the Internet, of course, and the word relationshippers is far too long of a word to use in normal conversation, the term was pretty quickly thereafter shortened just to "shippers."

How’s that for an ancient history lesson?

Even during the show’s run, however, the term "shipping" was rarely talked about outside of specific fan circles (namely, nerds on the Internet). Yes, there was media coverage focused on the fans who liked the idea of the couple getting together, but that coverage was never as widespread as it is today.

It’s not that people were less passionate about shipping back in the day though, lest you think that – they just had less of an opportunity to connect with the people behind the show and actually affect outcomes. Think of Mulder/Scully as the little ship that could – the relationship that developed despite the creator's best intentions (you can’t rewrite history now, Chris Carter, we know), and despite the fact that, for at least half of its run, the shippers weren’t even that vocal. In fact, for the inevitability of a Mulder/Scully romance I see in retrospect, watching live I was often convinced that it was never, ever going to happen.

(... Did it happen? Did I dream it? Are Mulder and Scully together right now?)

For me, shipping started with these two characters. I’ve evolved now, of course. I ship just about everything there is. But there was a time I didn't. And I spent much of my teenage years obsessing over gestures between Mulder and Scully and/or hoping for at least a hug between the two. And I wasn’t the only one, obviously. So what was it about them, you ask? (If you’ve never seen the show, this is a valid question. If you have, then… are you a noromo?) What was it about Mulder and Scully as characters and as a ship that drew such a passionate fanbase that we’re all still here -- talking about them -- twenty-two years after the pilot first aired?

Okay, I’m going to try my best to answer you. I really am. It’s probably going to take a lot of words in order to do so, because, well… the show lasted for eight eight seasons (technically nine, but we all try to ignore season nine), and there’s a lot to analyze. Too much, maybe.

And it started right from the pilot episode.

A LITTLE BIT OF CHEMISTRY GOES A LONG WAY

Chemistry between actors is a funny and an inexplicable thing. Sometimes the spark is there, sometimes it isn’t (and sometimes shows attempt to force chemistry out of two actors who don't, but that's another case altogether). And boy, do David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson have chemistry. They have so much chemistry, in fact, that sometimes I find myself wondering about if that chemistry translated to real life or originated there. As Mulder and Scully, though, the spark and sizzle was readily apparent from day one.

In fact, it was so apparent that before there were real signs of the ship in the writing itself, Chris Carter was already answering questions about the possibility of romance between the two leads. In an interview published before "Ghost in the Machine" (literally THE FIFTH EPISODE OF THE FIRST SEASON) aired, the show’s creator gave this response to a question about the nature of Mulder and Scully’s relationship.

“No, it’s a relationship that is much stronger and more passionate. First of all I would call it a cerebral romance, in that these characters sort of delight in each other’s approaches and it isn’t the pat or standard or expected television romance between them. There is no physicality between them. I don’t see it in the near future here. They don’t end up in the sack together. At least I don’t see it happening yet. I think it’s refreshing. I mean I was raised on shows like The Avengers which are smart and the characters were very attractive for those aspects. They didn’t have to end up in bed together.”

We should have known just by how defensive Chris Carter got (and by the fact that he felt compelled to deny the possibility of a romantic relationship three times in one paragraph) that he didn’t really understand what was happening between the two leads on his own show. (No physicality, Carter? What’s with the whole Mulder straightening out Scully’s necklace in episode three?!). But we’re not here to talk about Chris Carter and what he did or didn’t understand about the romantic relationship between Mulder and Scully. We already had that chat. We’re here to talk about what we saw, not what he saw.

(Hint: we saw plenty)

From the very beginning, the whole set-up of the series felt like a slow-burn couple with a clear endgame in sight. After all, Mulder and Scully were, in the early days of The X-Files, the only two characters you saw episode in and episode out. Have you heard the phrase “it’s you and me against the world”? Well, it WAS Mulder and Scully against the world.

And what a world it was.

A strange, strange world where unexplained was the norm, where evidence disappeared, where you were expected to report on your partner. A world where you’re given a job that -- just by accepting it -- would make you a pariah. A world where you’re the only one who can see the truth, and are ridiculed for it.

So, it was only natural that these two people would develop chemistry, that we would be drawn to them as viewers and invested in their relationship. When there’s no evidence of the crazy stuff you’ve seen, the only person who’ll believe you’ve seen some crazy stuff... is the person who was there with you for it. And yes, the show took Scully’s skepticism to extremes sometimes, mainly by having her conveniently “miss” most of the moments that would have proven Mulder right. But in general, Scully was always there for the weird and for the unexplained. She just usually managed to have a rational explanation for it.

This is the beginning, the basis for everything in their relationship. You have this person, this one person who’s there with you – there for you, and you sort of end up trusting that person by default. And then that trust is put to the test. (See "Ice" and "Darkness Falls" just in season one alone). And after a while, it’s not that you trust them because they’re there, and it’s easy. You trust them because they’ve proven themselves to you. That person has become your friend, your confidant – your partner.

THE EVOLUTION OF A SHIP

Early on in the show, we see Scully attempting to maintain a normal life outside of work. If we hadn’t, we might have -- as an audience -- wondered about her or have been concerned for her. Mulder was wholly devoted to his work from the start, for many, many reasons. He’d given up the pretense of a life outside of it. Scully, however, had to choose to join him on his quest. And join him she did – to the detriment of most of the relationships in her life.

There’s a moment in the season one episode "Jersey Devil" where Scully turns down a date to join Mulder in an investigation. He teases her about having a life, but it’s clear from that instance early on that Scully is choosing to make Mulder her life. She’s not choosing the quest, but him. She’s following him.

(Now read that line three times and tell me you don’t ship them.)

At the end of season one, after time spent fighting against the system all by themselves, our heroes are put in the stereotypical season-finale cliffhanger of being separated from one another. The X-Files are terminated, and Mulder and Scully must go their own ways. And I promise you that if you somehow made it through an X-Files initial watch (or re-watch) without somehow shipping Mulder and Scully, the premiere of season two is the moment you would start.

Because Mulder is depressed in that premiere. He has no evidence to back any of his claims. And, look, that doesn’t seem like a big deal. But understand this – HE’S NEVER HAD EVIDENCE. That has never really bothered him before. He was that lonely guy screaming at the sky before Scully. Now he’s better. He’s grown. He might not have all the answers, but at least now, thanks to the woman The Powers that Be assigned to debunk him, he’s asking the right questions.

And Scully’s grown, too. She’s the one to encourage Mulder not to give up. He’s expanded her world, just as she provided a foundation for his.

(Crying? Nah, I’m not crying. I just have a little something in my eye.)

And to think I've written this entire article and haven’t even gone into Scully’s abduction, Mulder’s rage, Mulder wearing her cross necklace for the entirety of that horrible episode where she was missing, Mulder’s rage again, when she returned, Scully’s family being all like: "we know you’re in love with her, dude," and that little moment when Mulder decides being with Scully is more important than revenge. We haven’t even talked about any of that yet, you guys.

And we won’t, mostly because we need to talk about something even more important that’s not often discussed. Mulder’s entire reason for – well, for everything, is his sister, Samantha. Samantha was abducted when he was 12 years old, and he not only blames himself for it, but dedicates his life to figuring out what happened. To finding her.

... ONLY TO TRADE HER LIFE FOR SCULLY’S WITHOUT A SECOND THOUGHT.

(And, yes, fine, that wasn’t the real Samantha, just clone Samantha. But he didn’t know that. Mulder really thought he was giving up his long-lost sister. Remember when you asked me, like a thousand words ago, why I shipped them? THIS IS EVIDENCE OF WHY.)

As an aside, just for those uninitiated into The X-Files, I’m not even up to the end of season three here.

There’s more of this throughout the series -- more of the same, and more of different ways to show love. I’m not here to do a play-by-play of all the Mulder/Scully moments for you, though. (For the record, I totally would be, but this has already taken many more words than I planned). I’m merely here to give you a glimpse into what made these two idiots the couple to ship back in the 90’s. I'm here to explain to you what made people who never watched the show when it originally aired be as invested in their relationship as I was when I was a teenager.

I'm here to explain to you what made Mulder/Scully the jump-off point for this crazy, beautiful, wonderful phenomenon called shipping. (And I hope I managed to do that.)

Because they were the starting point, there’s no doubt about it. Do you love a couple on TV today? Have you ever fallen in love with a fictional character’s love story? Do you enjoy fanfiction, the GIF sets, even the debates and meta commentary? Then take a moment to thank Mulder and Scully. Or, better yet, go watch them and THEN thank them.

The original ship always has room for one more member.

The X-Files returns with six new episodes beginning January 24th, 2016 on FOX.

Friday, August 7, 2015

Top 5 OTPs Fom Tragically Cancelled Shows [Contributor: Maddie Shook]

We’ve all been there. After weeks of anxiety of whether your on-the-bubble television favorite will survive the network executive’s swinging of the axe in May, the fatal blow occurs -- your show has been cancelled. You probably react a bit like this:


And thus, you have to say goodbye to your favorite characters now that they will no longer grace your television screen each week. This cruel separation is even harder when shipping is involved. These are the beautiful pairings that you have become so invested in after either a short period of time or a number of years. They have swoon-worthy moments that make your heart squeal in delight, angst that drove you straight to eating a whole pint of Ben and Jerry’s Half Baked, and scenes crackling with chemistry from start to finish. No matter how perfect the ship, the merciless cancellation cannon blasts apart critical darlings and hot messes alike. However, even when the show is admittedly a hot mess, your OTP is still your OTP and the pain is there, my friends. All melodrama aside, the greatest outrage that occurs when a perfect pairing’s show gets cancelled is all of the wasted potential.

The cruelty is not just in no longer seeing your OTP each week, but also never getting that kiss or love confession you were waiting for. You have invested in a love story that will forever remain unfinished. You’ve gone through all the stages of grief: shock and denial, anger, bargaining with petitions and hashtags, depression, and fanfiction; but the lack of resolution is something you may never actually get over. And that is precisely why I've created this post. Now, the list of such tragically unresolved pairings goes on and on, so I know that there will certainly be pairings you love missing from this list. But without further ado, here’s my list of top 5 OTPs from cancelled shows that I am still not quite over.

Monday, July 20, 2015

When Stories and Characters Develop Minds of Their Own: Of Mulder/Scully and Chris Carter [Contributor: Lizzie]


Everyone who calls themselves a writer dreams of one day getting one of those characters. You know what I’m talking about: the characters who write themselves, the stories that seem to develop without your input, and sometimes, even without your consent. As a writer, you create these characters -- these individuals, and then you turn around... and it’s like your kids grew up when you were busy with something else, and now they’re eighteen and running off with a motorcycle-riding boyfriend that you don’t approve of.

Ladies and gentlemen, may I present you exhibit number one: Fox Mulder and Dana Scully
Once upon a time (because that’s how every great story starts) Chris Carter had an idea. It was a revolutionary idea at the time, and he spent a lot of time developing it. He put a lot of himself into both Mulder and Scully -- his main characters. Carter created a strong woman who relied on science. He created a strong man who wanted to believe. And then he brought them together. And by "together," I mean he put them in the same space and time. He didn’t really mean for them to be together, together.

What Chris Carter really, truly wanted was to write about conspiracies. He was interested in the big picture, in the special effects, in the monsters-of-the-week. He wanted to write the weird stuff, the legends, the paranormal -- the things everyone had said again and again wouldn’t work on TV. He wanted an overarching mythology tying it all together. Mulder and Scully were his babies, yes, but in a way, they were just means to an end. He certainly wasn’t thinking about the romance.

The story has changed with the years, but the clues are everywhere. You might even say they’re unmistakable. "Chris Carter played the long-game with the Mulder/Scully romance," is the version they tell these days. And, who knows. That might be somewhat true. Or that might just be what Chris Carter wants to tell himself now that the romance is canon: people love it, and he’s basically got no other choice but to smile and say that, yes, he planned it that way all along.

Mulder and Scully have always loved each other, were always meant to be together; theirs just wasn’t a sexual kind of love, Carter’s said. (Which, if you think about it, really, really hard… no, no wait… it still doesn’t make sense). Currently, Chris Carter is saying that they are soul mates, but life has different kinds of soul mates. Soul mates, he is seemingly insinuating, don’t mean you’re going to be together forever and have babies; that’s just the mainstream ideal. Soul mates means something deeper, something ethereal, something that we can’t define. And we nod, and smile. Because he created these characters and he should know them better than us, shouldn’t he?

At this point, I’m starting to think the answer to that is no.

I was with The X-Files from the beginning. I was a little kid, sure, but I saw these characters grow from acquaintances to friends. I saw Mulder and Scully prove things to each other, time and time again. I saw them develop that trust, become partners. I was part of the journey, even if they couldn’t see me. I was the person they were selling this story to. And once they were partners, when you thought two people could not possibly get any closer without jumping in bed with one another, I saw Mulder and Scully move beyond even that. I saw them become family.

"Best friends" was always a label that somehow didn’t seem to encompass all that Mulder and Scully were to each other, and yet, for many years, it was the best phrase we could use to describe them. Sheila Larken, who plays Margaret Scully, once said “they’re [Mulder and Scully] best friends beyond what lovers could ever be.” And thoug that doesn’t really explain the depth of their relationship either, at least it goes beyond the bare facts, tries to explain that the relationship is an exception to a rule.

David Duchovny went even further, when he summed up the Mulder/Scully relationship this way: “It’s like the one friend, I guess, that he has in the world. I mean I heard a phrase once; somebody was talking about their wife. This was a person who was very inept socially, not the wife but the man. There were many things said about him that weren’t kind, and he said: 'My wife, who is lovely and social and everything like that, is my human credential.' And that makes him a human being, because people think, well if she can stand him, he must have some humanity within him. Sometimes I think about Scully as Mulder’s human credential. It’s the only thing that makes him not crazy, in many ways.”

Both quotes are right, and yet, in a way, neither one comes close to explaining all that Mulder and Scully were to each other. Not that my words will be any better. If you want to know what Mulder and Scully were all about, you have to watch the show, just like I did.

You see, this is not a second-hand story someone told me, not the legend of Mulder and Scully that was told through Tumblr posts or Facebook statuses. I was a front row witness to their journey from "You’re the only one I trust" to "I can’t live without you." It was slow, but it happened. And it didn’t happen in spite of their creator. I think Chris Carter meant it to happen.

... Okay, you're sitting there bewildered at your screen. You’re contradicting yourself, Lizzie. That is NOT what you said earlier. You said he was clueless. You said he didn’t know. Tell us... which one is it?

Bear with me and I’ll explain.

Chris Carter meant to create these wonderful characters. He was trying to meld them into partners. He wanted them to become close and depend on each other. I just think he didn’t see the romantic nature of what he was doing until it hit him right in the face. And, no, I’m actually not joking around here. So how can you create one of the most iconic romances in television without meaning to? you wonder. How can you have two people who defined the term UST (unsolved sexual tension) and not have it all be part of a grand plan?

Easy. With two very, very good actors who are excellent at seeing beyond the obvious, and a rabid fanbase who was just discovering the power of the Internet.

Welcome to Chris Carter’s personal hell.

One season in, The X-Files the questions were all about the conspiracy. Who was the Cigarette-Smoking Man? Who was Deep Throat? Were they really among us? Four years later, the questions were all about the characters: Were Mulder and Scully in love? Was Scully’s cancer incurable? Would Scully ever get to have a child? I’m not saying these were questions the writing team behind The X-Files was afraid of. I’m not even saying that they didn’t focus on these two wonderful characters, sometimes in detriment of the plot. All I’m saying is that they did not mean for the characters to overshadow the mythology. They did not mean for this to become the Mulder and Scully Show. And the certainly didn’t intend to create the gold standard for will-they-won’t-they couples.

Because for them, there was no real question. The answer was obvious: yes, Mulder and Scully loved each other. They loved each other as siblings, and they loved each other as spouses. They took care of one another. They were always there for each other, in good times or bad times. And that was much more important than whether they were actually having sex or not.

Okay, I hesitate to call them naïve, but boy, were they naïve.

Television is much easier to understand these days. Maybe it’s because actors, writers and producers get the chance to interact with fans more often on a deeper level. Perhaps it’s because of things like focus groups and test audiences. Shows today have so much more information than they did twenty years ago. Lead actors routinely go through chemistry tests before they get to actually film. They don’t often meet up randomly in the waiting room and just so happen to practice lines with each other and then, surprisingly get the roles.

Point is, in this day and age, show runners don’t have to guess what people want. They know. In fact, they so thoroughly know that, sometimes, they even delight in not giving fans what they know they want (at least not right away).

That was not what Chris Carter was doing, though (ignoring what fans wanted). At least, not at first. No, Chris Carter was just telling a story. A story about aliens, a big conspiracy, and the men behind it. An epic story. A story other shows would seek to emulate. Sometimes I see Chris Cater's interviews and can almost feel his frustration at the fact that even though he managed to create an iconic show... it really isn’t the plot we’re still talking about today, so much as the characters. I always remember this quote, and if you’re a die-hard X-Files fan like me, you probably remember it.

"Scully loves Mulder, and Mulder loves Scully. It's a wonderful romance. It's just not a sexual romance. It's not a physical romance. It is a caring, tender, respectful relationship. It's an ideal, and I would never want to do anything to threaten it, to change it."

That, from the mouth of their creator. I remember going through the five stages of grief after reading this. I’m serious; I actually went through the stages. Because this was Chris Carter acknowledging something, and yet, at the same time, not acknowledging it. This was him saying, yes, I see it, there’s love, but the rest is not there… the rest (that physical romance) is just your imagination.

(Spoiler alert: It wasn’t.)

This particular quote is probably the reason I sat down to write this article. At the time when Chris Carter said this, I was still young enough to put stock in his words. I’ve learned my lesson, of course. Never trust a show runner. They change their minds (Or, sometimes, like in this case, they have their minds changed for them). This is an important lesson, and it holds true for every fandom. But it especially holds true when it comes to Chris Carter, and I feel like I need to repeat it over and over again until it sinks in.

Never trust Chris Carter.

Ever.

In fact, let’s make that the tagline for the new episodes.

Mulder and Scully are what they are primarily because of David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson. From the beginning, David and Gillian were the ambassadors of MSR (Mulder/Scully romance). Back in the day, that was actually a pretty unusual thing. I don’t want to turn this into a fandom history lesson, but The X-Files was really the first big fandom to exist online at the same time as the product it derived from. Of course, that has a lot to do with timing. The X-Files was at its most popular just when the Internet was becoming something other than a cool thing you could use in the school computer lab. And, boy, were the fans loud. I would know. I was one of them.

And Chris Carter didn’t like it. Or he did. He loved it. He just didn’t love the reasoning. If nothing else, he wanted his audience to pay the same degree of passion and attention to the Mulder/Scully relationship as to the conspiracy. But love makes the world go 'round, and all that. Chris Carter was never actually going to get his way.

It’s funny how I keep thinking about all of this now that we’re so close to getting new episodes on FOX. You’re bitter, my friends say. You’ve been holding a grudge for ages. And, in a way, they’re right. I’m bitter. I’m scared. I don’t believe Chris Carter truly understands what he created, and because of that, I don’t trust him to treat these two characters with the respect they deserve.

There’s a beautiful quote from a sixth season episode called "The Rain King," that pretty much explains all these two characters are, and all that Chris Carter ended up creating:

"Well, it seems to me that the best relationships - the ones that last - are frequently the ones that are rooted in friendship. You know, one day you look at the person and you see something more than you did the night before. Like a switch has been flicked somewhere. And the person who was just a friend is... suddenly the only person you can ever imagine yourself with."

If you ask me, David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson flipped that switch long before Chris Carter wanted them to. They might have even flipped that switch without even recognizing what they were doing. They were these people, and when the natural progression of things felt right – they did them. And maybe after that, their creator, and the writing team in general, looked around and said: "Well, yes. Okay. That really does make sense. Let’s go for that. Let’s just do it our way."

And do it their way is precisely what they did, through nine seasons and two movies. They’ll probably continue to do it their way through the six episodes we’ll be getting next year. What "their way" means is anyone’s guess at this point. It probably means less of the explicit romance and more of the deep connection. But that’s okay. You want to know why? Because at this point, they can’t take it back. They can’t deny it. And, even if they make it hard for us, in truth, they’re not really trying. They’ve surrendered to the truth. Millions of fans and two actors saw way before they did.

Mulder/Scully is the OTP to end all OTPs. The one that started it all.

I have to end with this quote from Frank Spotniz, because if anything sums up what The X-Files ended up being, is these words: “You can’t get the truth. You can’t. There’s a larger truth, though: that you can’t harness the forces of the cosmos, but you may find somebody else. You may find another human being. That may be kind of corny and all of that, but that’s what it is: Love is the only truth we can hope to know, as human beings. That’s what Mulder and Scully found after nine years. And that’s a lot.”

Cheers to that!